And That’s When the Shit Hit the Fan

Okay, so, not long ago, fantasy romance author Elisabeth Wheatley announced that she could no longer in good conscience continue writing explicit sex scenes. Her reasons were faith based, and in a personal belief that since porn objectifies women, and she was essentially writing porn, that she should stop doing that thing. (Note: this is an extreme paraphrase of what I remember from her initial TikTok vid on the subject, so this is mostly what I took away from it.) She also stated she was going to be editing all of her previous works so that all the sex scenes would be “fade to black.” (She did state she was going to make sure that the readers who wanted the keep the sex scenes, would be able to keep them.)

I was…mildly perturbed by this, mostly because it seems she hadn’t wanted to write smut in the first place. (And also I literally don’t understand why someone would feel pressured to write something they didn’t want to–neurodivergence for the win!)

It didn’t make sense to me because there are lots of writers of romance and other genres who do not in any way write explicit sex scenes. There might be a certain sensuality to the writing, and it might be very delicate about the level of intimacy, that’s been achieved, and then you have a morning after and hopefully some cute as shit morning banter but it generally never gets what you’d call explicit. However, my perturbation was confined to Discord at the time, where I was mildly exasperated that a woman who didn’t actually feel comfortable writing sex scenes had been writing them. (Though it does explain why skipping them was so easy. Sex like any other action should be plot driven, folks, unless you’re writing “Plot What Plot.”)

The majority of her fandom were perturbed for another reason. That reason seems to be mostly due to a sense of entitlement of the kind fans of a work often assume. They were mad that she was editing out the sex scenes, and they said a lot of stupid, nasty things as angry fans who feel they are being insulted often do. (And yeah, I think these fans feel like they were being insulted for wanting to read smut, even though Wheatley did her level best to assure her readers that she wasn’t judging them. I can see how they might feel that way, but they are still, quite bluntly, being assholes.) I haven’t seen any of these screeds against Elisabeth Wheatley’s decisions, but from a recent TikTok, it does not seem as if any of these entitled twits are making the one argument about removal of the explicit sex scenes that would have at least made (some) sense.

Bluntly, there is a LOT of violence in her books. “Ordinary” violence such as combat and war, but also physical abuse, verbal abuse, toxic relationships and extremely fucked up abusive, toxic families. If you’re going to show all that, in egregious detail, and not have any problem with it–because a lot of it is couched in “the past is a different, very fucked up country,”– then why is consensual sex the thing you want to take out? What is it about consensual sex that it is less objectifying than torture, slavery, and all other forms of abuse that show up in her works? (I have feelings about Daindreth’s Assassin. Those feelings involve repeat regicide, and possible matricide and step-matricide. My feelings somewhat prevent me from continuing the series because I don’t think I’m gonna get what I want.)

So basically, I have no tolerance for people attacking a writer for wanting to go back and edit her work, especially when she’s bending over backward to make sure no one loses what they initially came to her table for. (There are lots of writers who have done this, changed stuff around for one reason or another. If Octavia Butler can put Survivor in Star Trek Novel Jail, then Wheatley can ellipses her sex scenes.) I personally think she could have done what Joy Demorra did with Hunger Pangs: True Love Bites, which was to have separate “sexy” and “fluffy” editions. (Though in Wheatley’s case it would be “Dark” and “Dark with Smut.”) But that’s just me.

Leave a Reply

One response to “And That’s When the Shit Hit the Fan”

  1. kdorian Avatar
    kdorian

    This. Yes.

    Like

Leave a Reply